by Phillip C. McGraw Hyperion, 2001 Review by Christian Perring, Ph.D. on May 15th 2003
Phillip McGraw, better known now as
TV's "Dr Phil," has a Texas forthrightness that will appeal to some
and put others off. He starts out Relationship
Rescue placing great emphasis on how his approach to helping couples in
trouble does away with all the theoretical nonsense of most major approaches to
therapy, and gets straight to the most important issues. He says most traditional therapy is a waste
of time and does not produce results, and he tells his readers that his
approach is directly aimed at changing relationships for the better. He prides himself on non-technical language
and an action-oriented style.
When it comes down to it, however,
McGraw's approach is very similar to most others. He aims at honesty and mutual acceptance. His approach fits in clearly with the long
tradition of American self-reliance and taking responsibility for oneself. His broad characterization of most other
purported solutions as embodying myths is in fact disingenuous and self-promoting. However, to be fair, this is a work of
popular self-help, and not a work of scholarly survey. His self-confidence and brashness are indeed
part of the appeal of this genre, since they should inspire confidence in the
reader. What's more, his list of ten myths include ideas that many people seem
to believe. Some people do believe that
a great relationship requires that couples agree on everything, or that a great
relationship must be without argument.
Especially impressive are his criticisms of the belief that a great
relationship cannot survive a flawed partner, and he gives an example of a
happy marriage where the wife heard voices and was probably schizophrenic.
The book starts out by asking
readers to perform an analysis of their feelings about their relationships, by
going through lists of questions under the categories of "Personal
Concepts Profile," "Relationship Health Profile," "General
Relationship Problem Profile," "Specific Relationship Problem Profile,"
"The Relationship Behavior Profile: Your Partner," "The
Relationship Behavior Profile: You," "Your Relationship Lifestyle
Profile," "Relationship Communication Test," "Chemistry
Test," and finally, "The Five Tough Questions." After going through these questions, anyone
with even a slightly pessimistic view of the world or with any self-doubts will
probably be sure that he or she has a relationship in deep crisis. However, McGraw's blunt but optimistic tone
will probably lift the reader's spirits again.
A distinctive feature of McGraw's
approach is his insistence that you should still engage in self-scrutiny and
self-criticism and see how you are responsible for the problems in your
relationship even if you think that all the problems are due to your partner. Most of the book focuses on changing one's
own perspective to a more positive one, rather than trying to change one's
partner. Some might be concerned that
this puts the burden on the partner who is already doing most of the emotional
work in the relationship -- more often than not this is the woman in a
heterosexual couple. McGraw seems aware
of these concerns but points out that if a relationship is going to improve,
someone has to do make the initiative, and in the end it should improve the
life of both people in the couple, so it is worth doing.
At various points in the book,
McGraw introduces his Christian religious beliefs into the mix, and even
includes some quotations from the Bible.
Some readers may find this useful, but others will probably find it inappropriate,
and it seemed to be an unnecessary addition to his main message.
It is virtually impossible to
provide any objective assessment whether the recommendations in Relationship
Rescue will be helpful to readers.
Obviously, McGraw has sold millions of books already, and so his
approach does have wide appeal, and this success does suggest that many new
readers will also find value in the book.
Speaking for myself, I find most self-help books almost unreadable
because they make me very anxious about my life. I did find, however, that listening to the abridged audiobook was
relatively easy -- McGraw's familiar voice and his firm conviction are
soothing. Whether one follows his
advice step-by-step or one simply listens to it for some general ideas, the
book could be useful as a way to help one focus on ways to improve one's
Perring, Ph.D., is Chair of the Philosophy Department at Dowling College,
Long Island, and editor of Metapsychology Online Review. His main
research is on philosophical issues in medicine, psychiatry and psychology.
DISCLAIMER: Information on this website is not intended as, nor should be interpreted as, professional advice or medical or clinical recommendations. Neither South Central Alabama Mental Health nor any of its directors, officers, employees, or representatives endorse or guarantee the references or sites listed. No inference should be drawn from the exclusion of resources not listed. IMPORTANT INFORMATION, PLEASE READ BEFORE CONTINUING: The information contained on this Web site is for general reference purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional medical advice or a medical examination. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health professional before starting any new treatment. Medical information changes rapidly and while South Central Alabama Mental Health Center makes efforts to update the content on this site, some information may be out of date. The topics presented in this website are meant only as a guide and should not take the place of medical or psychiatric treatment by a healthcare professional.